Despite initial setbacks, these nine FA deals could still pay off in 2026
Big free-agent deals often focus on immediate impact, but what happens when the early returns are underwhelming? It's time to explore the potential of nine players who faced challenges in their first seasons after signing multiyear contracts during the 2024-25 free-agent cycle. These players have the opportunity to turn their narratives around and make a significant impact in 2026.
- Jack Flaherty (Tigers): Flaherty's 2024 season was a rebound, but his free-agent market didn't meet expectations. Returning to Detroit on a two-year deal with an opt-out, he chose to stay with the Tigers in 2026, aiming to regain his top form.
- Jeff Hoffman (Blue Jays): Hoffman's World Series blunder might haunt him, but the Blue Jays are giving him another chance. Can he bounce back and reclaim his role as a dominant closer?
- Sean Manaea (Mets): After a stellar 2024, Manaea's second year with the Mets was marred by injuries and a poor ERA. He's aiming for a comeback in 2026, knowing the Mets have options for their starting staff.
- Tyler O'Neill (Orioles): O'Neill's 2025 campaign was plagued by injuries and inconsistency. With a new contract, he's determined to rebuild his reputation after a strong 2024 season.
- Joc Pederson (Rangers): Despite a disappointing 2025, Pederson's player option for 2026 gives him a chance to redeem himself after a slump in his final season with the Rangers.
- Anthony Santander (Blue Jays): Santander's shoulder injury and back problem in the ALCS didn't help his cause. The Blue Jays are counting on him to bounce back and contribute to their success in 2026.
- Tanner Scott (Dodgers): Scott's first season with the Dodgers was underwhelming, but with three years left on his contract, he has the opportunity to redefine his role and become a key late-inning reliever.
- Luis Severino (Athletics): Severino's contract was a significant investment for the Athletics, but his first year fell short. He's determined to prove his worth and become a cornerstone of the rotation in 2026.
- Christian Walker (Astros): Walker's first year with the Astros was a regression from his previous form. With a chance to recapture his top form, he's ready to contribute to the Astros' success in 2026.
