The film 'Endless Cookie' offers a truly unique blend of surreal animation and heartfelt storytelling that captivates from start to finish. But here's where it gets controversial—does its unconventional style enhance or hinder the emotional impact? This animated documentary isn't your typical narrative; it boldly combines visually arresting, hallucinatory imagery with deeply personal themes, challenging viewers' expectations of both documentary and animation forms.
The story begins with a straightforward account of how the project came to be. There are the Scriver brothers—Seth and Pete—who received funding through a grant to create an animated film together. Seth traveled from Toronto to live with Pete in the remote First Nations village of Shamattawa to brainstorm and develop ideas for their project. And while this origin story might seem mundane, the way it’s presented immediately draws you in with quirky visuals: a grant representative depicted as a bent ruler, Seth’s wife appearing with an onion-shaped head, and Seth himself as a pale, overweight figure with a blue nose—distorted, humorous, yet captivating.
As Seth discusses their ambitious goal—to craft something that is 'funny, beautiful, spiritual, political, complex, simple, and true'—the film visualizes these adjectives with emojis floating across the screen. It’s a playful, inventive way to immediately communicate the film’s eclectic mix of tone and intent.
Visually, 'Endless Cookie' is a feast for the eyes.Using a hand-drawn style that nods to indie comics from the 1990s, vintage video games, and children's picture books, the movie presents a grotesque yet beautiful dreamscape. Created by Seth, the animation is psychedelic and freeform. The universe it depicts only loosely obeys the rules of logic—imagine dogs shaped like peanuts, daughters made of cookies, talking pictures on the wall, and scenes shifting swiftly from present-day life to apocalyptic futures and back. These hallucinatory visuals might be overwhelming at times, but they serve a warm, human purpose: to tell a deeply relatable family history that resonates above the chaos.
Much of the narrative unfolds inside Pete’s living room, where many of the conversations from 2016 to 2024 were recorded. These recordings form the backbone of the film’s vignettes, building a mosaic of their relationship. The two share a father but have different backgrounds—Seth is white, and Pete is Indigenous—though they were raised together for a time in Toronto’s Kensington Market. As they talk, Pete shares stories he wishes to include, such as how he once got his hand caught in a beaver trap—an anecdote that exemplifies the personal and cultural elements woven into the documentary.
However, the storytelling doesn’t follow a simple, linear path. Instead, 'Endless Cookie' is a stream of consciousness—full of digressions that range from personal childhood memories of ordering terrible pizza with friends to stories from Pete’s large, lively family of nine children, ten dogs, and many relatives commenting on life in Shamattawa. Seth’s animation ventures into the absurd, parodying old video games or creating bizarre commercials, like one advertising a city made of toilets. These tangential episodes, difficult to distinguish at times, create an intentionally meandering but soothing narrative that feels like a warm, chaotic family gathering.
Despite its comedic surface, the film doesn’t shy away from political themes. Through visual cues—like a supermarket aisle filled with products branded with tongue-in-cheek names such as 'Let’s Eat the Billionaires Chicken Fingers'—and heartfelt stories from Pete’s family, it comments on systemic issues faced by Indigenous communities in Canada. An especially poignant section narrates the painful experiences of a family friend who was kidnapped and sent to one of Canada’s notorious Indigenous Residential Schools—highlighting historical trauma.
Yet, 'Endless Cookie' balances this heaviness with celebration. It underscores the importance of community, cultural transmission, and resilience. In a touching climax, black-and-white pictures of Pete, Seth, and their loved ones appear on-screen, creating a genuine feeling of intimacy. It’s a testament to the film's strength that viewers feel they come to know these characters—even if they are symbolized by simple cookies or cartoons throughout.
In the end, 'Endless Cookie' is a thought-provoking mosaic of visual experimentation and heartfelt storytelling. Its playful, sometimes chaotic style invites audiences to reflect on complex issues while enjoying a whimsical, surreal journey into family life and cultural identity.
Grade: B
Obscured Releasing will bring 'Endless Cookie' to theaters in Los Angeles and New York starting Friday, December 5.
For those interested in staying updated with more insightful reviews and filmmaking trends, consider subscribing to IndieWire’s newsletter, In Review, curated by chief critic David Ehrlich. It offers exclusive commentary, top streaming recommendations, and in-depth analysis—only accessible to subscribers.
